Prosecutors have been reminded to observe ethical standards and professional conduct, including adhering to the guidelines of their code for prosecutors.

The advice came from Justice Geoffrey Henderson, in an admonition to the two state attorneys who abruptly walked out of his courtroom after jurors, in a majority verdict, acquitted two policemen last week.

Henderson is a former director of public prosecutions (DPP). After their abrupt exit from his court before he discharged the jury, Henderson expressed his disappointment at the actions of prosecutors Brandon Sookoo and Dylan Martin. He said he reported the “discourtesy” to DPP Roger Gaspard, SC, to “deal with.”

On March 12, the two prosecutors received a dressing-down from the judge as they appeared before him at the Princes Town court.

“I cannot put into words how incredibly disappointed I was by your disrespect not only to me as a sitting judge but also to the Supreme Court when you walked out of the court...

“I don't know what spirit of madness came over you. Do not pay lip service to your code and be upset over verdicts or rulings you do not like.”

He said prosecutors were ministers of justice who operated by a code.

“A prosecutor secures no victory and sustains no defeats,” he said, quoting from the code for prosecutors produced by Gaspard on March 26, 2012.

“Your behaviour shattered my view of you…” he told the two state attorneys.

“I am not sure you misunderstood my easygoing nature to behave the way you did, to walk out the court when you didn't get a verdict you liked.”

Henderson also reminded that “undignified or discourteous conduct” was a reportable breach (to the Judicial and Legal Service Commission).

He said before last week’s incident, he had nothing but praise for the two as “the brightest, decent, and well-prepared” state attorneys. At first, he said, he told the DPP he no longer wanted the two to appear before him, but because Gaspard described them as “committed prosecutors,” he would work with whomever the directors sent.

But he warned, he would not tolerate discourteous attorneys in his courtroom.

“This is not Justice Henderson’s court. It is the taxpayers' court.”

Henderson read extensively from the code for prosecutors on the topics of role and ethics, impartiality, decision-making and the application of the full code test to determine if they were satisfied they had a case with a reasonable prospect of conviction and trial fairness.

“Evaluate if those are empty words.”

Henderson also said a judge’s summation (directions to a jury) was not a “second prosecution closing address,” and reminded of the appellate process if they are not pleased with a court’s ruling on a trial.

He further urged prosecutors to review their cases before bringing them to trial.

“The problem starts with the quality of the cases.”

He said bringing a case to trial with little prospect of success was a waste of scarce, valuable court resources.

“Low conviction rates undermine the criminal justice system. Start by referring to

Wakanda News Details

Web Portal of the Government of Saint Lucia

You may also like

Washington DC Facts

Black Sands Ultimate Edition Hardcover Release!

Sports Facts

Cuisine Facts

Politics Facts